Theory
X, Theory Y and Theory Z
During my last 2 years of work experience, I have the
opportunity to work in two different kinds of atmosphere. On one hand, the
working environment in Permali Wallace is flexible and employees are given
liberty to complete the project on time. On the other hand, I was part of BPCL’s project execution team in setting up Rs.10, 000 crore mega petrochemical
Plant in Bakania and the environment is quite opposite to Permali’s. Here the
majority of the workforce is semi-skilled and unskilled labour and management
need to be coerce and strict in job site to get the job done. However in both
the situations, it is seen the techniques used by managements are appropriate
and situation specific. Here comes the theory of X and Theory Y.
Theory X and Theory Y are theories of human motivation
created and developed by Douglas McGregor at the MIT Sloan School of Management
in the 1960s that have been used in human resource management, organizational
behaviour, organizational communication and organizational development. They
describe two contrasting models of workforce motivation.
Theory X:
Theory X basically holds the belief that people do not like
work and that some kind of direct pressure and control must be exerted to get
them to work effectively. These people require a rigidly managed environment,
usually requiring threats of disciplinary action as a primary source of
motivation. It is also held that employees will only respond to monetary
rewards as an incentive to perform above the level of that which is expected
From
a management point of view, autocratic (Theory X) managers like to retain most
of their authority. They make decisions on their own and inform the workers,
assuming that they will carry out the instructions. Autocratic managers are
often called "authoritative" for this reason; they act as
"authorities". This type of manager is highly task oriented, placing
a great deal of concern towards getting the job done, with little concern for
the worker's attitudes towards the manager's decision.
Theory X can be related to Taylor’s Scientific
Management Theory. According to Theory X and scientific management Theory what
motivated people at work is money. Worker’s sole satisfaction will be
maximizing his money. However in modern organizations, people required more
than money and here comes Theory Y into the picture.
Theory Y:
A more popular view of the relationship found in the work
place between managers and workers, is explained in the concepts of Theory Y.
This theory assumes that people are creative and eager to work. Workers tend to
desire more responsibility than Theory X workers, and have strong desires to
participate in the decision making process. Theory Y workers are comfortable in
a working environment which allows creativity and the opportunity to become
personally involved in organizational planning.
According to another of the authors studied for this
project, in which the "participative" (Theory Y) leadership style is
discussed, a participative leader shares decisions with the group. Douglas
McGregor thinks that Theory Y managers are more likely than Theory X managers
to develop the climate of trust with employees; a critical requirement for
human resource development. It's human resource development that is a crucial
aspect of any organization. This would include managers communicating openly
with subordinates, minimizing the difference between superior-subordinate
relationships, creating a comfortable environment in which subordinates can
develop and use their abilities. This climate would include the sharing of
decision making so that subordinates have say in decisions that influence them.
For McGregor, Theory X and Y are not different ends of the
same continuum. Rather they are two different continua in themselves
Theory Z:
Theory Z deals with the way in which workers are perceived
by managers, as well as how managers are perceived by workers; is created and
developed by William Ouchi. Theory Z offers the notion of a hybrid management
style which is a combination of a strict American management style and a strict
Japanese management style This theory speaks of Ringi System of Management. This
decision-making system is the collective decision-making process and is highly
decentralized. Only after the consensus is reached the decision is taken. If
the decision is successful, then the one who has advocated it gets the credit
but interesting part is that in the event of unsuccessful decision-making, top
management takes the responsibility for the failure. Theory Z emphasizes
things such as job rotation, broadening of skills, generalization versus
specialization, and the need for continuous training of workers.
Theory Z assumes that workers tend to want to build
co-operative and intimate working relationships with those that they work for
and with, as well as the people that work for them. Also, Theory Z workers have
a high need to be supported by the company, and highly value a working
environment in which such things as family, cultures and traditions, and social
institutions are regarded as equally important as the work itself. These types
of workers have a very well developed sense of order, discipline, moral
obligation to work hard, and a sense of cohesion with their fellow workers.
Finally, Theory Z workers, it is assumed, can be trusted to do their jobs to
their utmost ability, so long as management can be trusted to support them and
look out for their well being.
Theory Z stresses the need for enabling the workers to
become generalists, rather than specialists, and to increase their knowledge of
the company and its processes through job rotations and continual training. In
fact, promotions tend to be slower in this type of setting, as workers are
given a much longer opportunity to receive training and more time to learn the
intricacies of the company's operations. The desire, under this theory, is to develop
a work force, which has more of a loyalty towards staying with the company for
an entire career, and be more permanent than in other types of settings. It is
expected that once an employee does rise to a position of high level
management, they will know a great deal more about the company and how it
operates, and will be able to use Theory Z management theories effectively on
the newer employees.
comparison & Contrast of Management Theories
Conclusion:
No theory is bad or good. If we take into consideration of Maslow’s
hierarchy of needs, then it can be said that at the bottom of the pyramid,
money is the main motivator for work. Theory X managers exploit this human
behaviour characteristics to maximize organizational profit. It is
predominately seen in labour intensive work like GAIL’s petrochemical plant.
However as we go up in the pyramid, self actualization is the main
motivator.Theory Y managers tries to maximize organizational growth to promote
self esteem, confidence, achievement, respect of others, and respect by others.
No comments:
Post a Comment